Trade vs Terror: Time for China to Choose
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
Issue Courtesy: South Asia Monitor | Date : 07 Nov , 2016

India-China relations have been severely impacted by China’s open support for Pakistan on many fronts. One of the important areas where China seems to be least worried is cross-border terrorism affecting countries like India and Afghanistan. India has been a victim of cross-border terrorism for many years — the most recent being the September 18, 2016 Uri attack sponsored by its neighbouring country Pakistan.  

China’s stand on terrorism is baffling and it pains India more than any other country. New Delhi has been pressing the United Nations (UN) to declare Jaish-e-Mohammed chief Masood Azhar — operating from Pakistan — as an international terrorist who poses serious threat to humanity and disrupts peace and tranquility in the subcontinent. Unfortunately, Beijing has consistently blocked the Indian move. On technical ground, China has succeeded twice in delaying the UN’s decision on Masood Azhar.

China’s deliberate tactics of blocking India’s progress in international fora is quite evident. In June 2016 at Seoul, Beijing successfully blocked New Delhi’s bid for membership of the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG).

Pakistan may be China’s natural ally but India is one of the biggest trade partners of China. While China-Pakistan total trade stood at $12 billion in 2014-15, China-India trade was valued at $72 billion in the same year. During the period under consideration, China’s export value to Pakistan reached just $10 billion compared to export value of $60.4 billion to India. In short, for all practical purposes, India is 6 times valuable for the Chinese economy than Pakistan.

India’s trade deficit with China has been widening. It reached a high of $52.7 billion in 2015-16 and the April-July 2016 figure has already reached $15.9 billion. China’s ability to produce low-cost products addresses affordability issues of Indian consumers. As a result, the market in India is flooded with Chinese products.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has time and gain emphasised that terrorism has no boundary and religion. Beijing must realise that the global community rejects any form of terrorism.

All members of SAARC, except Pakistan, extended solidarity to the victims of the Uri attack and took a strong position against terrorism. Now Beijing should accept that any form of support, including diplomatic and moral support to any country promoting factories of terror to breed terrorist for export purpose, must be stopped.

During the 8th BRICS Summit in Goa (October 15-16, 2016), Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s message on cross-border terror was loud and clear, which is clearly reflected in the Goa Declaration, Point Nos. 57-59.

Hopefully, Beijing will take the Goa declaration very seriously and acts against terror-harbouring countries.

It is in China’s interest to carefully choose between support for free trade or cross-border terror in the region. For the time being, its actions suggest that Beijing is interested in both.  On the one hand, China is pressing for free trade area between BRICS nations and, on the other, it is protecting Pakistan for many wrong reasons.

China generates trade surplus through exporting a wide variety of products to India and reinvests some part of the surplus in Pakistan. Some of the major products categories that China exports to India include telecom instruments, computer hardware, fertilizers, organic chemicals and pharmaceuticals, plastic, iron & steel and ceramic.

In a sense, India indirectly funds Chinese projects in Pakistan, including the China-Pak Economic Corridor passing through Pakistan-occupied Kashmir.

The presence of China-made products in India is growing day by day. During the festive season, one could easily find China-made Indian idols and firecrackers dominating local markets. Often these China-made products offer cost advantage to traders, retailers and customers — resulting in high demand for Chinese products.

Many favour a blanket ban on Chinese products to reduce the Chinese trade invasion impacting small and medium-scale enterprises (SMEs) in India. However, with India being a member of WTO, such a ban is technically not permissible and feasible.

Click to buy

The government is equally concerned about widening the trade deficit with China and impact of Chinese goods on domestic SMEs.

Some of the best possible solutions include:

(a) Strengthening domestic manufacturing,
(b) Making domestic manufacturing globally competitive,
(c) Promoting innovations & start-up culture, and
(d) Creating manufacturing-cum-trading hubs.

The Modi government has already started many path-breaking initiatives like Make in India, Start-up & Stand-up India and Skill India to address the anomalies to make India a manufacturing hub.

These collective initiatives are going to strengthen the manufacturing sector and enhance global competitiveness of Indian firms. And, within a decade, India would likely emerge as a major global trading hub which may push China to revisit its own stand on terror.


Rate this Article
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
The views expressed are of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the Indian Defence Review.

About the Author

Sanjay Kumar Kar

is Head, Department of Management Studies, Rajiv Gandhi Institute of Petroleum Technology, Rae Bareli, Uttar Pradesh, India.

More by the same author

Post your Comment

2000characters left