IDR Blog

Afghan Fiasco – The end of a Unipolar World?
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
Slavisha Batko Milacic | Date:02 Oct , 2021 2 Comments
Slavisha Batko Milacic
graduated history at University of Montenegro. His specialist graduate thesis was: "Foreign Policy of Russia from 1905 to 1917". He participated in several seminars for journalists and analysts, organized in the Balkans. 

Anyone who ever tried to invade Afghanistan wasinevitably defeated. The multiethnic mountainous country has become a grave for the British, the Russians, and now for the Americans and their European allies. To make matters worse, the hasty US withdrawal from Afghanistan laid bare thepolitical weakness and inconsistency of the White House that created a sense of uncertainty in the camp of its most loyal allies.

Along with the defeat of Saddam Hussein in 2003, the 2001 US military operation in Afghanistan toavenge the radical Islamists terrorist attacks on American soil was a demonstration of Washington’s military effectiveness and diplomacy. In record time and with minimal losses, the United Statesestablished control over most of Afghanistan. However, the Republican administration of President George W. Bush was already at a loss as to what to do next. In 1945, the liberated Europe was offered the “Marshall Plan.” In 2001 and 2003, the liberated Afghanistan and Iraq were offerednothing. It seemed that successive US presidential administrations had simply forgotten the principle of “the well-fed will not rebel,and were doing everything to prevent the Afghan economy, if it ever existed, from becoming viable. The warlords who had sided with the forces of the “Northern Alliance” shamelessly plundered the provinces, which they were appointed to govern. The on-and-off guerrilla warfare and the “fight against drug trafficking” have left an estimated 1 million civilians dead. UAV operators and Air Force pilots killed and shot at will anyone who looked suspicious, while the special services of Afghan collaborators and Western allies tortured and killed with impunity anyone who they believed was in any way linked to the extremists. All this was playing right into the hands of the Taliban. In Islam they love those who become martyrs for the sake of their faith…

Winning the war in Afghanistan is almost mission impossible. The main enemy facing the soldiers of the international coalition is not a Taliban fighter with an assault rifle in hand, but the very way of life of the Afghan people, only a tiny fraction of whom embrace Western values. Even their last president, Ashraf Ghani, had to be “exported” to the country from the United States. The Soviet Union tried to fight traditional values ​​by building schools and hospitals; after the Russians left, their protégés held out for three years. The Americans and their coalition partners focused on helping the Afghan army. They also allocated huge funds for humanitarian projects only to see that money being eaten up by endemic Afghan corruption, which quickly infected US military officials themselves. How else to explain that, according to the most optimistic estimates by international organizations, from 2001 to 2020, the production of drugs in the country jumped from 180 tons to 10,000 tons?

Afghan peasants switched to drug production out of desperation. They had no other options. The Republicans seemed to have forgotten about their favorite policy, which says that “give a man a fish, he will be fed one day, teach a man to fish – he will be fed all his life’’. As a result, fishing rods – a successful economic reform were never given to the Afghans. All they got was an army of corrupt managers who roused hatred among the people. Government contracts worth billions of dollars enriched members of the US top military brass, who turned a blind eye to such actions by their subordinates as drug trafficking, the creation of field brothels and torture for pleasure. In fact, the army began to rapidly degrade and decay. That being said, it was still the US army. Degraded as it was, it was still able, with little help from allies, to keep the country under control, not letting it slide into chaos. However, that very same US army failed to effectively fight drug trafficking or prevent jihadists from entering the country from Pakistan.

As a result, the impoverished civilian population fiercely hated both the occupiers and their own elites. As well as Western values ​​in the form of women’s rights, education and medicine. Therefore, never becoming allies for the Afghan people, the Americans were suffering losses in the guerrilla war. And the generation, who could have been re-educated, was becoming suicide bombers and militants, increasing the number of coffins.

As a result, by the time Trump became president, the situation had already crossed the point of no return. It was imperative to change the entire military administration and the Afghan elite, crack down hard on corruption and wait another ten years for the reforms to bear fruit. Maybe in 2030, maybe in 2040, a peaceful and prosperous Afghanistan would become the best monument of American democracy. Most likely, it would be possible to convince the American electorate of the impossibility of leaving the country and handing it over to the Taliban, who are responsible for the deaths of thousands of peaceful Americans. There was no such political will though. Neither were competent and honest managers capable of transforming Afghanistan into a legal, viable state. As a result, the lives of American soldiers who died for democracy and billions of dollars of American taxpayers were not just wasted. They were wasted on national disgrace – the hurried escape from the Kabul airport, which Joe Biden cynically tried to turn into a victory.

However, his statement that the US military had accomplished its mission in Afghanistan is in stark variance with the fact that the country was back to where it was in 2001. Moreover, the West will now have to conduct a dialogue with the Taliban andwith the leaders of the radical Islamists who have the blood of American and European civilians on their hands. All the sacrifices were in vain, terrorism won, not by military force, but due to inconsistency, incompetence and sheer inability to calculate the consequences, which is unacceptable for a great power. In fact, the Biden administration has admitted its inability to defend the Western world against the chaos of radical Islamism. Obviously, the world needs a new protector, or a world policeman…??

Rate this Article
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
The views expressed are of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the Indian Defence Review.

Post your Comment

2000characters left

2 thoughts on “Afghan Fiasco – The end of a Unipolar World?

  1. The Americans lined with the other Anglos, Chinese, and Jihadis to loot the planet of resources and cause death destruction and keep the world divided.
    They have blood on hundreds of millions of people on earth and are roaming earth freely causing conflict every where and pretending to be the victims.
    Why do the Americans, or the Chinese, or the Europeans, or Jihadis not stay in their own territories. Why do they want to claim the all the land territory and resources as their own. Why cannot they share it with the rest of the world without being in total control? Are you trying to control the media and timing to say these people who were on picnic in the Hindukush mountains and enjoyed the hospitality and of their guests made SACRIFICES by disrupting the guests lives and lifestyles with drone strikes and eating free nans.
    All so called protectors should go stuff their asses with a lot paper, The sacrificial stink is heavy.

  2. Afghanistan was never conquered by foreigners is a myth. Babur came from Ferghana, conquered Afghanistan in Circa 1515. He was not a pushtoon, was Chaghtai Turk. His successors ruled Afghanistan till 1739, when Nadirshah drove them off. Moghuls ruled present day Afghanistan for approximately 224 years. Moghuls were anti Afghan and Moghul army till Auragzeb’s time did not recruit Afghans in imperial army.

More Comments Loader Loading Comments