Latest...
 
 

The War of Nerves in Pakistan: Q & A

 

Q: What is the likelihood of Gen.Ashfaq Pervez Kayani, Pakistan’s Chief of the Army Staff (COAS), staging a coup, seizing political power and imposing the rule of the Army till fresh elections are held?

A: Little likely. The present tussle of the Pakistan Army over the so-called Memogate scandal is against Asif Ali Zardari, who is the elected Head of State and Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. The Army has no grievance against Yousef Raza Gilani, the elected Head of Government. If Gen.Kayani wants to seize power, he has to overthrow the Head of State who is the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. Acting against the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces would be an act of treason.In the history of Pakistan, there has been only one coup against the Head of State---- by Gen.Ayub Khan, the then COAS, against the then President Iskander Mirza. On October 7, 1958, Mirza suspended the Constitution on the ground it was proving to be unworkable, imposed a martial law and appointed Ayub Khan as the Martial Law Administrator. On October 27,1958, Ayub Khan, who did not get along well with Mirza, forced him to go into exile in London and declared himself the President of Pakistan and Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. The coups of Zia ul-Haq in 1977 and of Gen.Pervez Musharraf in 1999 were against the elected Head of Government who was not the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. Zia and Musharraf had no difficulty in getting their coup validated ex-post facto either by a compliant President or judiciary or both under the so-called doctrine of necessity.

Gen.Kayani would not like to place himself in a position where he has to overthrow the elected Head of State of Pakistan and the constitutionally designated Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhury, the Chief Justice of the Pakistan Supreme Court, has made it clear on many occasions that there is no question of the judiciary validating a coup ex post facto under the doctrine of necessity.

If Kayani stages a coup against Zardari and fails to get it validated by the judiciary he would have committed an act of treason on two counts---for overthrowing his Head of State and for acting against his Supreme Commander. All the other senior officers, who go along with a possible coup plot by Kayani, would be liable to be tried for conspiring and acting against their Supreme Commander. Many of them may not want to find themselves in such a situation.

Q. Does that totally rule out the possibility of an anti-Zardari coup?

A. Not necessarily. If there is a serious law and order situation in Pakistan, the Army under Kayani may still stage a coup unmindful of the post facto legal consequences. One does not presently see the possibility of such a situation arising.

Q. If an outright coup is ruled out, what is the fall-back position available to Kayani to save his face?

A.The fall-back option available to the Army is to manipulate the situation in such a manner so as to make it untenable for Zardari to continue as the Head of State and the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces.The Army could achieve this by driving a wedge between Zardari and Gilani or by undermining Zardari’s political base in the Pakistan People’s Party. Such a contingency is unlikely. Both Gilani and the PPP have remained steadfast in their loyalty to Zardari so far.

A second option available to the Army is by having the COAS declared as the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. This would make it easier for Kayani to act against Zardari. In May last year, after the USA’s Abbottabad raid, a private person filed a petition before the Lahore High Court to have the COAS declared as the Supreme Commander of the Armed Forces. Such a change could be brought in only by a Constitutional amendment. With the PPP and its Allies having the majority in the National Assembly and in the provincial Assemblies of Sindh and Khyber-Pakhtoonkwa such an amendment is unlikely.

The other option available to the Army is to work and hope for an adverse ruling by the Supreme Court against Zardari in the Memogatecase.The possibility of the Supreme Court giving a direct finding against Zardari is weak now. Even ManzoorIjaz blames only HussainHaqqani, former Pakistani Ambassador to the US, for the contents of the Memo seeking US assistance to prevent a coup after the Abbottabad raid of May 2 last year against Osama bin Laden. He has not definitively blamed Zardari for the contents of the Memo.

The best the Army can hope for from the Supreme Court is for an adverse ruling against Haqqani holding him guilty of an act of treason for having sought the assistance of a foreign Govt for acting against the Pakistan Army. If the court gives such a ruling, Zardari could become an accomplice of Haqqani’s act of treason by virtue of sheltering him initially in his house and subsequently in Gilani’s house after Haqqani returned from Washington DC to resign.

Even in such an eventuality, the Supreme Court cannot act against Zardari unless the National Assembly in which the PPP and its allies have a majority lifts Zardari’s immunity against prosecution.

Q.Is there any political and honourable way out available?

A.The only honourable way out is by dissolving the National Assembly before its term expires in March next year and calling for fresh elections later this year. However, if the PPP and Zardari return to power in that election, it will pose an embarrassing situation for Kayani as well as the Chief Justice.

Pakistan is in for a long period of an excruciating war of nerves in which there will be neither honour nor victory for any of the dramatis personae

 
Rate this article
 
 
 

About the author

B Raman is presently Director, Institute for Topical Studies, Chennai & former Additional Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat. He is also the author of The Kaoboys of R&AW, Mumbai 26/11, Terrorism: Yesterday, Today & Tomorrow, Intelligence: Past, Present & Future and A Terrorist State as a Frontline Ally.

 

Reader's Response 28 Posts | Submit your Post

 
Posted on: May 22, 2012 at 08:01 AM
Posted by: Anonymous

"When Coach Cheap NBA Shoes Scott gets mad, he gets the rolls," said Irving, NBA Basketball Shoeswho received 117 out of 120 first-place votes from media members across the country. "My dad has done the same thing since I was a kid. You know not to mess with him nike running shoes men when rolls start popping on his face."When you look at them, there's so much passion and so much drive that they have. You just want to go out there and fight for them. You want to give them nike air max your best. Coach Scott just expects the best. He wants to be Nike Zoom Hyperfuse the best. He's going to do everything to get the best out of you."That's all you want and that's all my father wanted, so they share that similar trait. They let me be myself, http://www.nbabasketballshoes-cheapsale.com/ but if I was doing something wrong, they were going to tell me about it. If I Dwyane Wade was doing something right, they were going to congratulate me."

Posted on: May 9, 2012 at 02:39 AM
Posted by: beats for sale

Bright sunny earth, a few slices of clouds in the sky, and a pleasure to tune out on the green lawn, filled with the laughter of children. Here Constantine the Nice OurGame country is a very common community, this community, beats by dr dre studio in non-base can be seen everywhere, their responsibilities, is responsible for the residents nearby public lock thing and welfare measures, of course, in Constantine Nice Lianzhong country under such an excellent welfare system, these communities are run very perfect. Yellow gas volleyball for children across a beautiful solitary line in the sky, cheap beats studio the last light fell on a young female teacher hands. The children immediately surrounded pleased to up these children, are the children of this community, whenever the school or free time, they will to the community garden to play. The young female teachers also work in this community for several months, beats pro led the community is not high nor low salary, for everything here, have become accustomed to. "Jenny teacher, you can accompany us to play with?" Face red, a gold-colored hair flapping like Apple like a cute little girl asked, blinking blue eyes.

Posted on: May 9, 2012 at 02:38 AM
Posted by: dr dre

In addition, as the recording, mixing and playback tool. The deep bass response and clean sound across the spectrum, Beats Pro does not use noise cancellation circuit amplification or add other frequency sounds, beats studio australia specially designed earphones to provide additional space for a higher level of comfort and hearing, comfortable, breathable cushion to further reduce sweating, beats pro so you can enjoy music in a cool feeling. With advanced speaker design and power isolation technology, the Beats can make better use of power and energy to further enhance the sense of low-frequency power. beats pro headphones "Magic sound" headphones Rock, hip hop and R

Posted on: May 9, 2012 at 02:26 AM
Posted by: longchamp online

The controversy marks the latest setback for Yahoo, a Web pioneer that longchamp outlet has seen its popularity and revenue growth ebb amid competition from Google longchamp singapore outlet Inc, Facebook Inc and other online companies. Since taking the reins, Thompson authentic longchamp has moved fast to shake things up at Yahoo, laying off 14 percent of the staff longchamp sale last month and filing a patent infringement suit against Facebook. Thompson sent dre beats outlet an email to Yahoo's employees on Monday apologizing for the fallout from the controversy longchamp online and noting that he hoped the board's review would be concluded promptly, but has not publicly cheap beats by dre addressed the discrepancy in his educational background. longchamp singapore beats by dr dre

Posted on: May 9, 2012 at 01:28 AM
Posted by: Coach Outlet Online Sale

Coach Outlet Online Sale definitely one of the best bags with regard to travel along with obtainable in a variety of colors, the particular coach handbag is additionally shock absorbing as well as designed for stability and luxury. This brand graphic of coach can be built in its on going in top grade, principle in good quality and the particular unique fashion style. And next the trend elements were being integrated into your foundation. This means that its products have the timeless glamour. Coach brand dedicates to maintaining that classical in addition to quality with all the combining the top part craftsmanship, durable functions while using concision, elegant in addition to delicate pattern.Coach bags are in the belief that it is usually a classic and never goes from style, so they're worthy every anything you settled.

Louis Vuitton Outlet purses and you think it is actual you should not be buying a bogus. You will also see on many of the websites that they are promoting Louis Vuitton Handbags at a reduced price price and in most situations is it is use then the price can be reduced but if it is company new and the price is to excellent to be actual then is probably is. In our everyday life, the value of harness to men can not be changed by other components. An excellent beIt can signify males design and social position. Whether you use enjoyment way or in official design, Louis Vuitton harness will be your best option.

Louis Vuitton Outlet every style aware person knows clearly what the well-known high-class company Louis Vuitton has gotten for their style lifestyle. No one could give a certain number that how many individuals in this world have ever purchased or used LV products, no matter you buy them from a louis vuitton outlets shop or franchised shop. I

Posted on: May 7, 2012 at 09:13 AM
Posted by: manman

Anyway, this could possibly be the truth, you are not improve speed. Krugman job bernanke, on Sunday nyt “piece, Cheap Longchampdoes not do adequate to criticism of solving the issue of higher unemployment. Longchamp Le Pliagethought, a temporary higher level of inflation may possibly be needed (and not in question) to help reduce unemployment. affordable lLongchamp Bags,Longchamp OnlineThe additional deadly (and most extensively picked-up) review, geeked about “in a science fiction, and never econowonk, this method of comparison, Ben bernanke in the infamous” star trek “fame, writing, bernanke refused to look at higher inflation concentrate on getting a show possibilities he has long been converted right into a hive ideas half-robot-the servant.

Posted on: May 7, 2012 at 08:20 AM
Posted by: manman

Once enquired instead tiny acquire any particularLongchamp Outlet regardless if merely just one would most in all probability appetence to support you ascendancy a crucial recognized backpack, a complete great offer of method frames would most in all probability positively yes. Longchamp Bagsis certainly the just one among producers that other individuals could possibly be ruin as it.Longchamp Le PliageHaversack Haversack is without the need of a doubt acclimatized a crucial allotment in France, inside the street in Paris you will come about throughout every solitary person as well as every solitary person set up ascendancy a crucial Cosmetic Bags affordable handbags .Even regardless of the actuality how the abounding of aggregate of Longchamp Le Pliage Medium Tote, bodies aswell are abandoned for it. The complete aftereffect in that keeps a abounding adjustment of bodies in accretion to individuals branded accoutrement is expensive. afterwards which why so a abounding adjustment of individuals are accessible to blot a agitating movement additional forLongchamp Le Pliage MediumNo, it is not just an accessory. It is in ability a acclaimed Longchamp Hobo Bag. it is the acquire any abnormality of its quality, aftereffect and status.As we acicular much more than that companion in aloft in Post your Reply | Forward | Report Abuse | View Replies (0)

Posted on: May 7, 2012 at 01:05 AM
Posted by: Cheap Louis Vuitton

Louis Vuitton, il est l'un des plus remarquables de l'histoire fran?aise gourou de conception en cuir,louis vuitton moins cher a ouvert la boutique première valise en leur nom propre à Paris en 1854.louis vuitton sac pas cher Un siècle plus tard,louis vuitton pas cher sac Louis Vuitton est devenu l'un des meilleurs marques de bagages et de maroquinerie domaine,louis vuitton pas chere et est devenu un symbole de la haute société.sac louis vuitton pas chere Aujourd'hui, Louis Vuitton, la marque ne se limite pas à la conception et la vente d'articles de maroquinerie haut de gamme et des bagages, mais à s'impliquer dans le domaine de la mode,sac louis vuitton speedy pas cher accessoires, chaussures, sacs, bijoux, montres, des médias,sac louis vuitton speedy damier de vin et d'autres méga-tendances des indicateurs. Annuel à Paris stade T en constante évolution LV défilé de mode,Acheter Louis Vuitton Sac Pas Cher Louis Vuitton a pu a été debout au sommet de l'industrie de la mode internationale,sacoche louis vuitton pas cher la position, la fierté dans le classement de la liste des marques de luxe,chaussure louis vuitton dès le stade précoce de la valise Louis Vuitton pour le présent dans sa propre et unique ADN de la marque.sac louis vuitton moins cher Louis Vuitton bagages est la premièr

Posted on: May 6, 2012 at 07:59 AM
Posted by: Coach Factory

What to find a Fashion Coach Outlet that can suit for your everyday life? Coach Factory Outlet is your best choice! You can hardly find other stores like us. When you want to attend the important party, you can find that Coach Handbags Outlet play a important role in everywhere. More and more country import our Coach Outlet, so in order to build more foreign market, we can improve our quality of products and develop new products to meet the growing needs of people.Come to Coach Outlet , you own our warmest welcome and best after-sale service. Coach Outlet is one of the most trendy and multifunctional Coach Factory Outlet, it can give you much convenience for your life. This fashionable and stylish Coach Outlet is hot sale in our Coach Factory Outlet Online.Carrying Coach Outlet must let you be charming,attractive and fashionable.Welcome to our Cheap Coach Factory,if you need any informations of Coach Factory Outlet Online products, please contact us.Welcome to Coach Factory Online. Coach Factory Outlet offers distinctive, easily recognizable, accessible luxury products that are relevant, extremely well made and provide excellent value. Our own Coach Outlet Online having legitimate top quality,lovely pattern and also preferen

Posted on: May 3, 2012 at 12:23 PM
Posted by: nobelboy

a fashion designer shoes store for you. Christian Louboutin is about to have his craft showcased in a special exhibition at London's Design Museum, resume editing

Posted on: May 2, 2012 at 02:55 AM
Posted by: gucci

Dr Naxos, louis vuitton bags really cool product is very popular designer brand Louis Vuitton in the fashion world is a real angry person. The leather is very soft, built-in cotton lining, these bags of Naxos is the real value of money. In addition, it has a double zipper and removable ID tag and a man's classic colors, Blue Ocean, and taupe. louis vuitton handbags is not only the style and fashion, but also because they have a lot of space to carry when they go out favorite items. So, if you are waiting and thinking, handbags, only for women, then it's time to buy a Louis Vuitton designer handbags.Very interested in women's fashion! Therefore, would not be surprised if the majority of women choose to spend most of their wages to buy the latest products to support their performance. In most cases, they always choose the handbag as an attachment, because it has many of the features of their own appearance. If you are a handbag, you are certainly familiar with louis vuitton outlet, fashion women around the world to become the most popular choice. If you think this is very expensive, you can buy Louis Vuitton handbags provides website Ifyreplica.com on hundreds of copies of Louis Vuitton handbags ready to cope with a copy of your appearance.louis vuitton for sale is the most famous brand, because it has the highest quality! Lots of package price, up to hundreds of dollars, only a few can buy cheap louis vuitton. Therefore, this site offers the same design, excellent quality and low price, so it is the best alternative for your fashion replica handbags.cheap louis vuitton bags replica handbags

Posted on: May 2, 2012 at 02:55 AM
Posted by: gucci

louis vuitton borse breve - spesso chiamata la casa di moda francese fondata nel 1854 da Louis Vuitton borse. E 'ben noto che la combinazioni di lettere LV, la maggior parte dei prodotti dal bagagliaio della pelletteria del lusso e ready to wear, scarpe, orologi, gioielli, accessori, occhiali da sole, e libri sulla borsa etichetta Louis Vuitton è la leadership nel campo della moda internazionale casa uno. Marchi Louis Vuitton e il marchio più importante è tra il famoso Monogram LV. Le borse borse louis vuitton, secondo una ricerca condotta da Millward Brown nel 2010, dopo che il mondo dei 29 brand più prezioso, Wells Fargo ed ex Gillette. Lo stesso marchio è stato stimato a 1,9781 miliardi dollari. Il sesto anno consecutivo, Louis Vuitton è ancora di Ming Millward Brown Optimor BrandZ lo studio pubblicato nel 2011, del valore di 2,43 miliardi dollari, 10 uno dei brand più potente. Popolare contemporanea è più del doppio del valore dalla seconda posizione dal 19 ° secolo, nella produzione di merci per vuitton borse non è cambiata: il bagaglio è ancora fatta a mano, prevede l'attuazione di bassa pressione Preview tronco: "artigiano coerente con pelle e tela, toccando un piccolo chiodo, per garantire una ripresa solida in cinque lettere per dimostrare che la progettazione di blocco in ottone, in modo che i passeggeri possano avere una sola chiave di tutto il suo bagaglio, louis vuitton outlet la chiave per personal cornice fatta a mano in legno di ogni pioppo 30 vecchio tronco anno era stato lasciato a secco per quattro anni almeno ogni tronco ha un numero di serie, e può durare 60 ore, fino a 15 ore valigia "Louis Vuitton di uscita:. Idee di viaggio, durevole, la filosofia minimalista ed elegante viaggio, dal 1854, l

Posted on: April 29, 2012 at 12:25 PM
Posted by: yi zhu, Jr.

Down by the salley gardens my love and I did meet; She passed the salley gardens with little snow-white feet. She bid me take love easy, as the leaves grow on the tree; But I, being young and foolish, with her would not agree.fashion season zIn a field by the river my love and I did stand,And on my leaning shoulder she laid her snow-white hand.She bid me take life easy, as the grass grows on the weirs;But I was young and foolish, and now am full of tears.cheap replica swiss watches z

Posted on: April 27, 2012 at 05:12 AM
Posted by: discount oakley sunglasses

Discount oakley sunglasses as a bright light eye protection glasses, but also play an important role in the field of fashion accessories. oakley juliet popular in the market, one of the biggest reasons is the Oakley combines fashion elements and the health of not only the best eye care health, but also to the appearance on the increase in bright spot . Whether it is in the details of the deal, or in the processing of the frame style, sense of oakley eyeglasses tassel style lines highlights the elegant temperament, at first glance you will fall in love with it! Major sunglasses brands have dotted box type fashion classic and stylish elements you want to win the attention of consumers, but the classic has been imitated, never surpassed, such as cheap oakley sunglasses. Oakley is in the forefront of high-end fashion brand sunglasses, optical quality, is a framework designed to make people's eyes light up, every oakley sunglasses cheap product launch is bound to set off a new round of trends.

Posted on: April 25, 2012 at 07:19 AM
Posted by: Coach Factory

Coach Factory Niuyue Mai The re-opening the first flagship store in Dixon Avenue; Cheap Coach Handbags a symbol of its important position in the fashion industry in the United States; the the Zhongshan flagship store opening in 2006; 2005 Louis Vuitton UK Niuyue Mai The re-opening the first flagship store in Dixon Avenue; Reed Krakoff earned his second CFDA annual Accessories Design Award in 2004; 2003 Coach Factory Outlet Logo (Mini Signature) series; Tokyo Shibuya store opened in 2003 Coach bags sale Tokyo Ginza flagship store opening in 2002; Louis Vuitton Japan branch was established in 2001; authorized Steelcase production of furniture; Reed, Krakoff, to obtain the annual CFDA Accessory Design Award; introduction of Beats y dr dre Logo (Signature), jewelry, travel and other series;

Posted on: April 25, 2012 at 07:02 AM
Posted by: Bestech

Bestech believes that it has an edge in the field of Real Estate Development because the group has the combined strength of conceptualization with 100% implementation and delivery.
Bestech park view grand spa gurgaon
Bestech park view ananda
Bestech gurgaon
And
raheja gurgaon
raheja dharuhera
raheja projects in dharuhera

Posted on: April 21, 2012 at 03:39 AM
Posted by: http://www.discountoakleysunglassess.com

In Basement, Hopes to Solve ’79 Case of Missing Boy.Investigators swarmed into the basement of a building in SoHo on Thursday oakley flak jacket sunglasses with jackhammers, pickaxes and orders to carry out the most extensive search to date for the remains of Etan Patz, a 6-year-old boy whose disappearance more than 30 years ago focused national attention on the problem of missing children. oakley frogskins sunglasses More than a decade ago, Mr. Miller invited the police to come in and examine the basement, suggesting that they could tear up the floor if they wanted, but that they would have to pay to replace it, a person involved in the inquiry at the time said. oakley juliet sunglasses Because Mr. Miller was not a suspect, they did not take him up on his offer, the person said. Mr. Ramos was said to have admitted that he was with Etan the day he vanished, but denied abducting and killing him.Etan’s father, Stanley Patz, did oakley jawbone sunglasses not return a call for comment on Thursday.

Posted on: April 17, 2012 at 03:26 AM
Posted by: cheap ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray ban sunglasses

cheap ray bans

ray ban wayfarer

ray ban sunglasses sale

ray ban outlet

ray ban online shop

ray ban optical

Posted on: March 2, 2012 at 01:46 AM
Posted by: ariakery999

I have been searching for quite some time for information Buy Term Paper on this topic and no doubt your website saved my time and I got my desired information. That's not really a really huge statement, Buy Research Paper but its all I could come up with after reading this. You know so much about this subject. So much so that you made me want to learn more about it. Your blog is my stepping stone, my friend. Thanks for the heads up on this subject. Buy Book Report

Posted on: March 1, 2012 at 12:31 PM
Posted by: monster beats tour micro by dr dre

Thank you beats by dre promo reveal this article, casque beats by dre compose seriously beats by dre rouge is extremely wonderful beats by dre

Posted on: February 29, 2012 at 01:31 AM
Posted by: hermes constance

See how stars like steelers jersey and Charlize Theron wear spring's sultriest styles from off-the-shoulder tops to peplum cheap jordan shoes to leg-baring leather shorts,time it’s European line Marni with creative director Consuelo Castiglioni giving the fast fashion consumers exactly what they want.The silky tops with cheap steelers jersey bold prints coupled with tailored but feminine pieces mean this hermes constance one of those collections that will be gone in the blink of an eye.jordan shoes for cheap she began her style career while still a child, by cheerfully violating numerous dress codes at her private school. constance hermes so you’ve finally accepted that you’ll never walk down the real red carpet on Oscar night … but you can still pretend in high style cheap air jordan shoes.

Posted on: February 29, 2012 at 01:29 AM
Posted by: hermes constance

See how stars like steelers jersey and Charlize Theron wear spring's sultriest styles from off-the-shoulder tops to peplum cheap jordan shoes to leg-baring leather shorts,time it’s European line Marni with creative director Consuelo Castiglioni giving the fast fashion consumers exactly what they want.The silky tops with cheap steelers jersey bold prints coupled with tailored but feminine pieces mean this hermes constance one of those collections that will be gone in the blink of an eye.jordan shoes for cheap she began her style career while still a child, by cheerfully violating numerous dress codes at her private school. constance hermes so you’ve finally accepted that you’ll never walk down the real red carpet on Oscar night … but you can still pretend in high style cheap air jordan shoes.

Posted on: February 10, 2012 at 07:32 AM
Posted by: Anthony Pierce

The Army took up a position which indirectly endorsed the demand for a judicial inquiry on the ground that the allegations made by Ijaz, if true, had national security implications. -The Balancing Act Lifetime

Posted on: January 12, 2012 at 12:34 PM
Posted by: a raja

An informative and well researched paper some of which might prove to be a prophecy.

Post your Comment: