Did the British Really Divide India to Rule?
While studying Indian history in school days, one was repeatedly told that the British resorted to ‘divide and rule’ policy to gain control over India. The tone and tenor of such a description painted the British as unscrupulous schemers who exploited the simple, trusting and gullible Indians. As a young student one accepted the above statement at its face value without any questions and grew up in the belief that we Indians are a highly united lot and our subjugation was due to devious tricks and policies of the British.
At a later stage, one started wondering why Indians let themselves be divided by outsiders and why they could not foresee the result of their disunity. Sadly, the truth is that our approach, attitude and practices have always been directed towards remaining disunited. Caste system divided the society in distinct segments. Presence of multiple religions, sects and sub-sects in the sub-continent prevented social cohesion.
…the truth is that our approach, attitude and practices have always been directed towards remaining disunited. Caste system divided the society in distinct segments. Presence of multiple religions, sects and sub-sects in the sub-continent prevented social cohesion
The much touted Swayamwar (selection of spouse by a princess in an open forum) is indicative of this deficiency and our total disregard for forging unity. Whereas matrimony amongst the royals in the Europe has always been an instrument of forging strategic alliances, Swayamwar invariably created more enemies than friends. All rejected princes and kings felt insulted, nursed a grudge and waited for an opportunity to take revenge to redeem their self-esteem. History bears testimony to the fact that every Swayamwar was followed by acrimony and internecine wars.
Reverting back to the role of the British, they never divided us to rule. They did not need to do so. We have always been and continue to be a divided lot. Formation of states on linguistic basis was never attempted by the British. Mandal Commission was not constituted or implemented by them. Nor was the Babri Masjid demolished by the British.
The current agitation in Maharashtra has not been initiated by the East India Company. Caste based reservations and quota system, the prime splitter of the Indian body politic, were not invented by the erstwhile rulers. Nor are they preventing us from enacting a uniform civil code. The list is endless.
We have a knack and penchant for generating innovative issues to divide ourselves. We are doing our best to ensure that we remain embroiled in petty bickering and internal dissentions. To us, our region, religion, caste and sub-caste are more important. Worse, we flaunt this narrow identity and give it precedence over nationalism. If after 60 years of independence, Kashmir and the North East are still not emotionally integrated with the country, the failure is ours.
If India continues to exist as a nation, credit will be due to three institutions – the armed forces, the higher judiciary and the Election Commission. They are also the only hope.
Undoubtedly, the politicians are the fountainhead of all fissiparous tendencies. One does not have to be a visionary to predict the danger of abetting illegal migration from Bangladesh for garnering votes. North Indians in Mumbai are not welcome but illegal Bangladeshis can stay. If political leaders can imperil national security for the sake of power, they can stoop to any level. Sadly, they cannot be expected to change as they believe in the ends and not the means employed. To them, vote bank politics preclude letting countrymen stay united. Additionally, spineless and politicized bureaucracy simply follows their dictates and cannot be expected to deliver either.
Immense damage is also being inflicted on the unity of the country by the media through its irresponsible and thoughtless reporting. For the sake of cheap sensational news, petty vandals are given the coverage befitting a mass leader. Every news item is reported with a religious, caste or creed slant – ‘a dalit girl molested in a Delhi bus’ (as if other women are not molested in Delhi buses) or ‘church guard killed’ (in reality an argument between two security guards had turned violent) or ‘muslim driver runs over a boy’ (his being a muslim is of no relevance). It is obnoxious to see articles spelling out proportions of different castes in a constituency and predicting victory of the candidate from the majority caste, thus promoting caste based politics.
The Way Ahead
If India continues to exist as a nation, credit will be due to three institutions – the armed forces, the higher judiciary and the Election Commission. They are also the only hope.
As regards the armed forces, the nation owes its security, both external and internal, to its apolitical nature and nationalism. It is a symbol of national integration and a repository of best human values. It is an island of discipline and orderly behaviour in a sea of chaos and anarchy. A foreign observer wondered whether India deserved such a fine organisation. Unfortunately, concerted efforts are being made to demean and demoralize this shield between cohesion and disintegration.
If an Indian citizen still respects law and believes in its fairness, the credit is entirely due to the independence and pro-activity displayed by the higher judiciary. Having been let down by the Parliament and the executive, people look at the judiciary as their sole hope. Therefore, it must step forward to shoulder additional responsibility, opinion of conservative constitutional experts not withstanding.
In a secular country where religion is a highly emotive issue, it is best to shift all religious activities from public domain to private domain.
First, anyone promoting hatred between communities or undertaking divisive actions should be punished for anti-national activities or even treason/sedition, as internal dissentions are the start point of all civil strife.
Secondly, cost of all damages caused to public and private property must be recovered from the leaders of the vandalizing mobs with deterrent imprisonments. In case of fatalities, they should be charged with murder.
Thirdly, any government found abetting disorder, both through overt support or tacit inaction, should not be allowed to stay in power.
Fourthly, a blanket ban should be put on all religious processions and use of loudspeakers in religious places. In a secular country where religion is a highly emotive issue, it is best to shift all religious activities from public domain to private domain.
The Election Commission can play an extremely important role with its constitutional powers. Any party that does not swear by the integrity of the country and equality of all citizens should be banned. Similarly, any party that promotes hatred amongst various segments of Indian society on any grounds whatsoever must be proscribed. Even religion-based parties which disallow followers of other religions as its members should have no place in a secular country.
It is the duty of the Election Commission to ensure that political parties are not allowed to play vote bank politics at the cost of national cohesion. All defaulting parties and their leaders must be handed out exemplary punishment, debarred from standing in elections and their political careers sealed.
The British controlled the whole of Indian peninsula with a maximum of 60000 troops. Today every state has a police force of more than that strength and yet divisive forces are rampant. If India has to survive and prosper as a united nation, it is time corrective action is taken. Let us not force the next generation to rewrite the history books to say that India can remain united only when subjugated by a foreign power or that an independent India is always a divided India.
About the author
Maj Gen Mrinal Suman is India’s foremost expert in defence procurement procedures and offsets. He heads Defence Technical Assessment and Advisory Services Group of CII.
Most Popular
Lancer Military Bookshop
Interviews / Spotlight
Interview with Rear Admiral KN Vaidyanathan, Director General Naval Design
Shivalik, the first Ship of the P-17 Class, appears different from earlier designs of IN ships. What are the major new design features of this class of ships? Please...
Read More
Archives
© Copyright 2012 Indian Defence Review
After that, we put intense study, many students the holiday is not willing to go home, to nest in the classroom efforts to review, on the college entrance examination in June, they have to pay close attention to the time of one minute. beats for sale The Dandan irritability of the heart calm down, past the passion back, just not Qi Cai in the day she and some are not used to, because Qi Cai holiday home to rest, Yiyi holiday back. Yiyi would like to her Xiaocai brother with him to teach their own learning, beats for cheap she felt that learning up to a multiplier. Listen to the words of Qi Cai, she no longer every day, stay in the classroom to read, go out a run, get some fresh air, the results still rapid helicopter, although it is not the class first, but almost the same. dre beats As a result, she admire Qi Cai from the bottom of my heart, this guy really have a set of known odd materials, his thoughts deepened, May Day holiday she was thinking of coming back.
The human voice is very prominent, the positioning is a portable headphone. The noise reduction effect is very good, my dad knocked on the door in my bedroom door knock waited a long time I have not heard, monster beats headphones but also did not hear the voice of the Z5500's. And similar shure the pth effect can amplify the voice of the nearby, this design is very convenient. Beats Pro is the follow-up product of the 2008 Studio Beats flagship products, beats studio durable. In addition, specially designed black cable with the headset itself, the color harmony, the interface uses a special approach, to make the link more reliable. beats studio headphones Beats by Dr. Dre is the well-known audio wire suppliers Monster joint U.S. hip-hop music parent Dr.Dre launched headphones brand. Beats Pro is the follow-up product of the 2008 Studio is the flagship product of the Beats, the professional musicians of the DJ and music rooms, design, and convenient listening ear muffs can be flipped.
Coach Outlet Online Sale definitely one of the best bags with regard to travel along with obtainable in a variety of colors, the particular coach handbag is additionally shock absorbing as well as designed for stability and luxury. This brand graphic of coach can be built in its on going in top grade, principle in good quality and the particular unique fashion style. And next the trend elements were being integrated into your foundation. This means that its products have the timeless glamour. Coach brand dedicates to maintaining that classical in addition to quality with all the combining the top part craftsmanship, durable functions while using concision, elegant in addition to delicate pattern.Coach bags are in the belief that it is usually a classic and never goes from style, so they're worthy every anything you settled.
Louis Vuitton Outlet purses and you think it is actual you should not be buying a bogus. You will also see on many of the websites that they are promoting Louis Vuitton Handbags at a reduced price price and in most situations is it is use then the price can be reduced but if it is company new and the price is to excellent to be actual then is probably is. In our everyday life, the value of harness to men can not be changed by other components. An excellent beIt can signify males design and social position. Whether you use enjoyment way or in official design, Louis Vuitton harness will be your best option.
Louis Vuitton Outlet every style aware person knows clearly what the well-known high-class company Louis Vuitton has gotten for their style lifestyle. No one could give a certain number that how many individuals in this world have ever purchased or used LV products, no matter you buy them from a louis vuitton outlets shop or franchised shop. I
Mulberry Outletsomewhat really should complete rather than to always be ashamed of this kind of creating, aMulberry Sales it is, or perhaps, at least, could be created, more help to society when compared witMulberry Bagsh just about any community hard-on. In short, for you to sign witMulberry Factory Shoph no more reasons perforMulberry Handbags m, Mister Northerton
I loved these post.Thanks for sharing this informative post....offsite backup service
Sector is definitely crammed having large variety of ray ban sale sunglasses but if you are searching to get fashionable and trendy pair of wholesale ray ban wayfarer uk, subsequently grab maintain of your superb selection at the public internet site associated with ray ban aviator uk marketers. Simply just rest as part of your den and search for the great pair of aviator sunglasses sale that has a simply click associated with computer mouse. This wayfarer sunglasses sale are usually mainly designed with top quality fabric and extremely violet protected contacts for all you males who desire in order to beautify contemporary and developer glance.
Nike Shox brings out brand new versions Nike Mens Timberland Authentic Roll-Top Boot-White Grey Sportswear presents the following returning even to another pair of Nike Shox new advancement variety. Nike Shox features fresh variations Nike Sportswear delivers Mens Timberland Authentic Roll Top BOX Boots-Grey White this particular rear to an alternative pair of Nike Shox completely new development selection.Promoting several chaussures nike shox Clearance... Naturally, Wal-Mart's premier company is... It's basic to acquire nike shox footwear... You can find various Nike Shox easily.The business -- all kinds of other corporations accomplish the identical business -- promoting several Nike Shox Wholesale affordable throw away things. Sturdywoman nike shox chaussures may be thinking about the life of your grandson, not his life, let me the same day the king I is not doing.Think so, but just as classic The child said, Soldes chaussures nike shox vital nz femme offrir nike chaussure shox nz dollar femme.It can be uncomplicated to get nike shox... One can find a number of Nike Shox easily... Minnesota couple missing in Italian ship.Tn Requin Shoes are certainly an essential part of our clothes not as it brings style into your style however it provides safety to your toes. The Nike shoes for basketball incorporate the latest features and shoe technology,Jordan Shoes For Sale Cheap in the case of Nike Shox nz-004 shoes, with fly fit technology at the upper side which offers maximum support.
This sort of Cheap Timberland boots us to the next thing I like about the new portal – transparency. Timberland Roll-top Boots is not afraid to provide its readers with the bad news with Timberland Store. Call it radical transparency, or Timberland hiking Boots you want to give it, but the bottom line is Timberland the only way to act if you want readers to take your CSR report seriously. As a study Timberland For Kids and SustainAbility Timberland Boots On Sale, readers are looking for Timberland Chukka Boots to report on bad news. When bad news is reported, greater legitimacy is attached to the report, and it Timberlands For Men as more balanced.
I like to spend my free time by scaning various louis vuitton bags internet recourses. Today I came across your blog and I located it is as one of louis vuitton bag the best free resources available! Well done! Keep on this quality! We're a group of volunteers and also starting a fresh louis vuitton purses initiative inside our neighborhood. Your posting provided us with beneficial information to help us begin. nice one for taking the time to discuss louis vuitton outlet this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your website louis vuitton luggage with more information? as it is extremely helpful for me. I thought it was going to be some louis vuitton diaper bag boring old site, but I'm glad I visited. I will post a link to this site on cheap louis vuitton handbags my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful. Valuable info and first class figure you got here! I would like to. thank you for sharing your thoughts and about time into the louis vuitton wallet stuff you post ! ! This is a good piece
Unfortunately, concerted efforts are being made to demean and demoralize this shield between cohesion and disintegration.as their sole hope. Therefore, it must step forward to shoulder additional responsibility, opinion of conservative constitutional experts not withstanding.no deposit casino
linguistic basis was never attempted by the British. Mandal Commission was not constituted or implemented by them. Nor was the Babri Masjid demolished by the British.sperm banks
Even your beloved "Phauj" is divided. Otherwise would an honest and a highly decorated officer such as Gen. VK Singh have been removed by his own army in such an Extra-constitutional manner?Also the way the So called Supreme court cheated the Army out of any real justice shows that in todays India SC has become a modern rendition of a feudal Court. All this is possible because the bureaucrats know that the "Phauj" is so busy in fighting amongst themselves that they can never pose a united front to the bureaucratic supremecy(Extra-constitutional).The So-called nation has lost. Because the Army has refused to support its honest officers. Honesty is not welcome - seems to be the message given by the SC and the govt. to the rank and file.So dont go down the history lane to a 160 years ago to investigate the divided/infighting india. Is very much the same today and just like then , it appears to be crumbling from within. The question is have you guys in the So-called Indian military learnt any lessons from your past mistakes?All that your Army is capable of , it would seem, is harrasement of Civilians and Rape and Plunder of defense land and Commissions from Foreign Defense deals - and Off course Flogging the regular pet Horse - PAAAAKISSSTAAAN !!!!! (Boogeeeeeyyyyyymaaaaaan!!!!) . ps: No One seems to mention that Pakistan (BooooogeeeeeyMAAAAN !!!!) , is half the size of Madhya Pradesh. It merely shows the indiscipline and incompetence of the "Phauj". The Conflict with Pak is merely another example of short sided Feudalism (Divisive Indian Mindset) which runs to the top of your Army .
Everyone loves what you guys are usually up too. This kind of clever work and exposure! Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve included you guys to my blogroll.Essay writing || Assignment Help || Coursework Writing Services || Custom essay writing service || Dissertation help || University Essays UK
Nice informative post
Your approach to this topic is unique and informative. I am writing an article for our school paper and this post has helped me. Thanks.Encouraging Quotes
Another great example of innovation, I am glad to find it. There are so many developers working on this segment but this is one of the best innovative idea ever. Thanks for sharing it here.jas pria
I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and have my children check up here often. I am quite sure they will learn lots of new stuff here than anybody else!Mold Testing Chicago
I am not sure why the British would do this. This is not right at all. There needs to be some changes with this. big rig accident attorneys orlando