IDR Blog

PM Modi's Call to Dalai Lama is a Message to China on Succession Issue Important
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
Claude Arpi | Date:10 Jul , 2021 1 Comment
Claude Arpi
Writes regularly on Tibet, China, India and Indo-French relations. He is the author of 1962 and the McMahon Line Saga, Tibet: The Lost Frontier and Dharamshala and Beijing: the negotiations that never were.

Late one evening in August 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had an unheralded meeting in Delhi, with the Dalai Lama, the Tibetan religious leader living in exile in India since March 1959. Apparently, the meeting did not go too well; the reason is unknown.

The fact remains that for centuries India and Tibet, have shared values, not only in the spiritual realm (Mt Kailash, the sacred mountain of the Hindus is in Tibet after all), but also political, having a peaceful common frontier (which unfortunately for India, become the Sino-Indian border in 1954), without forgetting extensive economic and trade connections with the entire Himalayan belt, from Demchok in Ladakh to Kibithu in NEFA (today Anjaw district of Arunachal Pradesh).

Post 2014, there was minimal institutional exchange between Dharamsala and Delhi, except for a discreet visit of the (‘Buddhist’) Foreign Secretary (Harsh Vardhan Singla) in July 2020.

It is why it came as a pleasant surprise when the Prime Minister tweeted on July 6: “Spoke on phone to His Holiness the @DalaiLama to convey greetings on his 86th birthday. We wish him a long and healthy life.”

This simple call, made public via Twitter, is significant for a number of reasons.

First, it comes after the February 2018 MEA Directive, Foreign Secretary Vijay Gokhale asked the Cabinet Secretary to issue a “classified circular advisory advising all Ministries/Departments of Government of India as well as State Governments not to accept any invitation or to participate in [n the 60th anniversary of the Dalai Lama’s arrival in India].”

Delhi followed the old Nehruvian concept that by pleasing China, Beijing would reciprocate in kind. Remember that this was after the Doklam episode, when China tried to change the status quo at the trijunction Bhutan-Tibet-Sikkim.

Then the ‘Wuhan Consensus’ took place in April 2018; Xinhua then observed: “Chinese President Xi Jinping and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi reached broad consensus on the overarching, long-term and strategic issues of global and bilateral importance”.

The Modi Sarkar thought India could work with Xi Jinping.

It was followed by the ‘Chennai Connect’ in October 2019; the leaders of both countries announced that they would “prudently manage their differences and not allow differences on any issue to become dispute.”

On the final day of the two-day informal summit at the sea-side resort of Mamallapuram, it was decided to ‘consolidate strategic communication’.

Tibet and the Dalai Lama became dirty words, not to be pronounced by anybody in India.

Ironically, it is China who helped Delhi come out of its torpor; the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) advanced in several areas in Ladakh in May 2020, at a time when India was struggling with the Wuhan virus, widely acknowledged to have originated in the mega city, which had witnessed the ‘Consensus’ less than two years earlier.

It was a big shock for most of the ‘China experts’ in India, who for years banked on a great (not to say eternal) friendship with Communist China.

In a way, this phone call rebalances India’s China Policy (if there was ever one) at a time Beijing prepares for the post-Dalai Lama era by putting in place strict ‘regulations’ to be able to decide who will be the 15th Dalai Lama (preferably from a good Communist family).

Interestingly, Radio Free Asia (Chinese broadcast) recently reported: “Just as the CCP’s centennial celebration ceremony are about to start, the CCP imposed regulations on Tibetan Communist Party members for their religious behavior. [Since April] …all learning materials for Party members and cadres …need to adhere to atheist norms. …Party members and cadres should not believe in religion, to participate in religious activities, [they should] not spread or promote religion, [they should] not provide support for religious activities …without authorization [of the Party].”

Isn’t it amazing? The Party does not believe in religion, but simultaneously wants to select and impose its own Dalai Lama.

The phone call hopefully indicates that though India, a secular state will not intervene in the Dalai Lama’s succession; it will stand by the Tibetan leader’s decision.

Since China unnecessarily started a confrontation in Ladakh, one lakh Indian troops remain on vigil in the formidably harsh climate of the northern borders; the fact that the Prime Minister wished the Dalai Lama is certainly an important message across the Himalaya that the old relationship between Tibet and India is very much alive, specially before the 12th round of talks which is soon to take place between the Indian Commander of 14 Corps and his Chinese counterpart.

It is particularly significant as the PLA is trying its best to recruit more Tibetans in its ranks, to one day raise a Tibetan unit to match the Special Frontier Force (SFF), composed of Tibetan refugees in India; the SFF fought so well in August 2020, conquering the Kailash range, south of the Pangong Lake, for the Indian Army.

One can only hope that the initiative of the Prime Minister will be a first step to make the contacts between Dharamsala and Delhi more regular, in particular to jointly work for the preservation of the Buddhist tradition, another domain where atheist China is trying to lead the world.


Rate this Article
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
The views expressed are of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the Indian Defence Review.

Post your Comment

2000characters left

One thought on “PM Modi’s Call to Dalai Lama is a Message to China on Succession Issue Important

  1. Good friendly, inclusive relations with Tibetan leader, Tibet Govt. in exile and in general with Tibetan population across the globe is win win for both sides. Once bitten, twice shy should be the formula to deal with China: do not trust them nor do try please them for the sake of pleasing, they will stab us the back at the appropriate time. It has been been proved time and again. Face the Chinese aggression forcefully and chalk out a detailed China, Tibet policy and follow it with due diligence.

More Comments Loader Loading Comments