Geopolitics

Macabre Irony – Peshawar massacre
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
Issue Net Edition | Date : 17 Dec , 2014

In the wildest of macabre irony to the ‘good’ and ‘bad’ Taliban theory that Pakistan successfully sold to the US, comes the ghastliest of terrorist attack at the Army Public School, Peshawar snuffing out some 132 young lives and injuring over 200 children and staff. If Jeff M Smith writing in Washington Times of 23 April 2011 said, “Pakistan is playing a double game… The ISI supports Islamist militants…Pakistan believes it needs a pliant, anti-Indian regime in Afghanistan and – as it has for decades – Pakistan is using Islamist militants as an extension of its foreign policy”, BBC Documentary ‘Secret Pakistan’ provided further proof of Pakistan’s ISI training, advising and directing the Taliban. Nawaz Sharif may lament in Peshawar and pronounce that guilty may be punished but not without reason the editorial by Najam Sethi in Friday Times, March 16-22, 2012 (Vol XXIV, No. 65) surmised, “The ISI has walked into GHQ and seized command and control of the armed forces”.

The Pakistan army consists of 500,000 active duty troops and another 500,000 on reserve. If Pakistan truly wanted to capture the Haqqani Network they would be able to drag them out of their caves by their beards within a few days…

The obvious fact that he didn’t need to elaborate was that the military had taken control of the country called Pakistan, what with its institutionalized radicalization and continuing state policy of terrorism. That Pakistan (read the military) has been supporting Al Qaeda, Taliban, Haqqani network is well acknowledged by Western scholars as well as officials – including US-NATO officials posted in Afghanistan. As for the terrorist attack on Army Public School, Peshawar media reports that the innocent school children were lined up and shot in the head and chest – as if the Taliban wanted to prove they were as barbaric as the ISIS. But then the Pakistani army has been as barbaric, if not more, while the West and China have looked the other way, one example on the social media being:

Akin to the Taliban, Pakistan has also been playing the game of good and bad Haqqanis. Michael Hughes, Geopolitical journalist had written as far back as 06  July, 2010, “Pakistan’s army chief General Ashfaq Kayani asserted his forces were too bogged down fighting the Pakistani Taliban elsewhere in South Waziristan, Orakzai Agency and various districts across the NWFP. I contacted an Afghan intelligence analyst  and he assessed General Kayani’s claim with one single word: rubbish.

The Pakistan army consists of 500,000 active duty troops and another 500,000 on reserve. If Pakistan truly wanted to capture the Haqqani Network they would be able to drag them out of their caves by their beards within a few days…..In a movement that should have floored US policymakers, Kayani was brazen enough to try and inveigle Afghanistan to strike a power-sharing arrangement with the Haqqanis. And Kayani, apparently the spokesperson for the Haqqani group, said they’d be willing to split from and denounce Al Qaeda, which is President Obama’s primary rationale for the war. However, there is a higher probability of General Kayani converting to Hinduism than there is of the Haqqani Network ever being decoupled from Al Qaeda.”

Both Taliban are inexorably linked and in turn are linked to Al Qaeda, ISIS and Pakistan’s ISI.  Bulk TTP declared allegiance to ISIS while Al Qaeda chief has declared full support to Mullah Omar.

What are the Taliban today – both in Afghanistan and Pakistan? Both Taliban are inexorably linked and in turn are linked to Al Qaeda, ISIS and Pakistan’s ISI.  Bulk TTP declared allegiance to ISIS while Al Qaeda chief has declared full support to Mullah Omar. While ISIS pamphlets were distributed in Peshawar (including to Afghan journalists) and in border provinces of Afghanistan, number  of Wahabi-Salafi groups in Af-Pak backed by Saudi Arabia including in Nuristan & Kunar Provinces of Afghanistan have pledged support to the  ISIS. Groups like Ahraul Islam (another TTP splinter) and ETIM also think on lines of ISIS – rule of Sharia, Islamic Caliphate / Emirate. Significantly, Pakistani Asim Umar nominated Al Qaeda’s South Asia head. Sartaj Aziz, Advisor on Foreign Affairs to Pak PM talking to BBC recently said, “Pakistan should not engage in a war with those [insurgents / militants] whose target is not Pakistan.” He obviously was talking with organizations like LeT in mind but his advice hardly matters to the Pakistani military. That is why Pakistani military operations against TTP and Haqqanis (Operation Zarb-e-Azb) remained superficial as per eye witness accounts since radical leaders were forewarned and permitted to flee.

Yes, Pakistan is suffering from terrorist attacks but that is the price that must be paid for spawning decades of terrorism. US ignored LeT on premise it would only target India but then LeT cadres started joining Al Qaeda and calling for global jihad. Post the Army Public School, Peshawar massacre, Indian media poser is whether this will be a turning point in Pakistan. Such an idea may appeal to the utopians but is unlikely to happen. By all accounts, terrorism in the region is only going to go up.

Myra MacDonald wrote about Pakistan’s newfound confidence thus on 10 Dec, 2014, “When Lt-Gen Asad Durrani, a former head of Pakistan’s ISI agency, delivered a speech on Afghanistan in London last month, it was hard to miss the note of triumph. Afghanistan, he said, had already seen off two major world powers – the British Empire in the 19th century and the Soviet Union in the 20th. Now a third, the United States, was heading for the exit. For anyone who believes Pakistan’s aim in Afghanistan all along has been to turn the clock back to September 10, 2001 – when it exercised its influence over the country through its Taliban allies – it could almost have been a victory speech.” It is for this reason that Pakistan has been training 20 Mujahid battalions to operate as / in conjunction Taliban after the already ended ISAF mission in Afghanistan.

To think that Pakistan (read Pakistani army) will have change of heart because of the massacre of school children in Peshawar would be naïve. Pakistan’s policy of terrorism against India and Afghanistan is not likely to change.

An editorial in Pakistan’s  Express Tribune on 04 April 2012 read, “Just as the Soviet Union was defeated by a combination of Afghan Mujahedeen and Pakistani warriors, this time too Pakistan could infiltrate its non-state actors to achieve the ‘strategic depth’ it requires to feel safe about its northwestern neighbor. What is scarier for the world is the perception that Pakistan doesn’t control its non-state actors hundred per cent, as demonstrated by the Punjabi Taliban fighting the Pakistan Army in parts of FATA.” The areas / regions of Afghanistan that come under Taliban control will give “Pakistan’s ISI the ability to create a clandestine empire composed of the likes of Jallaluddin Haqqani, Gulbuddin Hekmetyar, and the Lashkar-e-Taiba : able to confront India in the manner that Hezbollah and Hamas confront Israel”, as described by Robert H Kaplan in his book ‘The Revenge of Geography’. Pakistan’s opportunity in Afghanistan needs to be viewed in context of the Independent Assessment of the Afghan National Army (ANA) conducted by CAN, as authorized by the US Government under the 2013 National Defense Authorization Act, Section 1215, findings of which published in January 2014 stated, “Reduction in US and NATO CI-CT operations combined with the continued existence of insurgent sanctuaries in Pakistan will make the insurgency a greater threat in the 2015–2018 timeframe than it is now” and “The ANSF will continue to have significant gaps in capability that will limit their effectiveness after 2014.”

To think that Pakistan (read Pakistani army) will have change of heart because of the massacre of school children in Peshawar would be naïve. Pakistan’s policy of terrorism against India and Afghanistan is not likely to change. Let up against Afghanistan is only possible if the Kabul government is anti-India and pro-Pakistan, which is not the case today, or if the Taliban are adequately represented in the Afghan government, which too appears an unlikely scenario. As far as India is concerned, we should have no hesitation to acknowledge that Pakistan will keep upping her proxy war to the maximum extent possible, official support to Hafeez Saeed’s recent anti-India rally in Lahore, state security to Dawood Ibrahim, non-closure of ‘Karachi Project’ and not punishing perpetrators of 26/11 Mumbai terrorist attacks being just few examples.

Rate this Article
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
The views expressed are of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the Indian Defence Review.

About the Author

Lt Gen Prakash Katoch

is a former Lt Gen Special Forces, Indian Army

More by the same author

Post your Comment

2000characters left

5 thoughts on “Macabre Irony – Peshawar massacre

  1. I really dont understsand that why cant the Indian establishment take out the LET leadership by covert means. Is Raw dead or the Indian mind is so pacifist that we cant think about that. We should initiate drone attacks against these targets. I know it will take a lot of planning and risks involved but how about taking a go at it. Lets show we have have two balls or else be prepared to face the music.

  2. THE MAD HAFEEZ SAYEED , THE DICTATOR GENERAL MUSHARAF AND THE
    RETD HEAD OF ISI GEN RET HAMID GUL ARE BRAZEN ENOUGH TO BLAME INDIA FOR THE GHASTLY MURDER OF ANGEL CHILDREN . THE INDIAN ESTABLISHMENT, ARMY , POLICE AND PARA MILTARY HAVE THIER JOB CUT . IN DELHI DETACHMENTS OF ARMY MUST BE SEEN IN ALL SECTORS . THE NSG SRG IN SMALL GROUPS BE STATIONED AT PRESIDENTS ESTATE , SAFADURJUNG AIRPORT AND SIMILARLY IN NORTH EAST WEST AND SOUTH DELHI , INCLUDING NOIDA AND GURGAON . ALL BIG TOWNS AND CITIES , VULNERABLE AREAS , SCHOOLS , HOSPITALS , HOTELS , VAS AND VPS RAILWAY STATIONS AND BUS STANDS NEED TO BE COVERED BY POLICE ARMED BATTALLIONS , PARA FORCES AND ARMY REGIMENTS IN PEACE STATIONS . THE LET AND TALIBAN INCLUDING ISIS AND ALQUEDA ARE PLANNING , AND WAITING TO ATTACK INDIA AND INDIANS CANNOT WAIT TO BE SLAUGHTERED . A STRIKE BY THE TERRORISTS MUST BE REPULSED WITH AIR STRIKES ON THE LET HQ AT MURIDKE AND ALL KNOWN TERRORISTS HIDING IN PAKISTAN ELIMINATED IN TARGETED STRIKES BY THE AIRFORCE . THE INDIAN PUBLIC INCLUDING LEVEL HEADED PAKISTANIS SPEECHLESS AND TRAUMITISED BY THE MINDLESS KILLINGS OF CHILDREN WILL ALSO ENDORSE INDIA STAND AS ONE PAKISTAN RETD GENERAL AND A AIRFORCE OFFICER ACKNOWLEDGED PAKISTANI MISTAKES IN RAISING THE SNAKES IN THE BACKYARD . the police para forces need to oil the rifles and guns and carry out intense training in the firing ranges with their old rusted rifles if they are to match the suicidal jihadis as was seen on telivision during mumbai attacks .

  3. THE MAD HAFEEZ SAYEED , THE DICTATOR GENERAL MUSHARAF AND THE
    RETD HEAD OF ISI GEN RET HAMID GUL ARE BRAZEN ENOUGH TO BLAME INDIA FOR THE GHASTLY MURDER OF ANGEL CHILDREN . THE INDIAN ESTABLISHMENT, ARMY , POLICE AND PARA MILTARY HAVE THIER JOB CUT . IN DELHI DETACHMENTS OF ARMY MUST BE SEEN IN ALL SECTORS . THE NSG SRG IN SMALL GROUPS BE STATIONED AT PRESIDENTS ESTATE , SAFADURJUNG AIRPORT AND SIMILARLY IN NORTH EAST WEST AND SOUTH DELHI , INCLUDING NOIDA AND GURGAON . ALL BIG TOWNS AND CITIES , VULNERABLE AREAS , SCHOOLS , HOSPITALS , HOTELS , VAS AND VPS RAILWAY STATIONS AND BUS STANDS NEED TO BE COVERED BY POLICE ARMED BATTALLIONS , PARA FORCES AND ARMY REGIMENTS IN PEACE STATIONS . THE LET AND TALIBAN INCLUDING ISIS AND ALQUEDA ARE PLANNING , AND WAITING TO ATTACK INDIA AND INDIANS CANNOT WAIT TO BE SLAUGHTERED . A STRIKE BY THE TERRORISTS MUST BE REPULSED WITH AIR STRIKES ON THE LET HQ AT MURIDKE AND ALL KNOWN TERRORISTS HIDING IN PAKISTAN ELIMINATED IN TARGETED STRIKES BY THE AIRFORCE . THE INDIAN PUBLIC INCLUDING LEVEL HEADED PAKISTANIS SPEECHLESS AND TRAUMITISED BY THE MINDLESS KILLINGS OF CHILDREN WILL ALSO ENDORSE INDIA STAND AS ONE PAKISTAN RETD GENERAL AND A AIRFORCE OFFICER ACKNOWLEDGED PAKISTANI MISTAKES IN RAISING THE SNAKES IN THE BACKYARD

  4. The Third World War: The School Children Front: This is unlikely to bring Pakistan’s flirtation with Islam to an end. If anything it may cement relations further between the two violent school children massacring states of the US and Islam. The rest of the world including the UK, India and the NATO nations will, in all probability, continue their macabre dance with this “religion of peace” Islam’s greatest achievement is the eradication of human conscience.:

  5. Lt Gen Katoch reasoning makes perfect sense. These innocent children were sacrificed in the internecine war between the Islamic terrorists and the Pakistani military that sponsored them. I agree, no perceptible change will occur and the people of Pakistan will continue to be brainwashed by the military/ISI nexus. Their imaginary war is against the kaffirs in India and if they can only settle the scores among themselves, they can move on to fight the real enemy India.

More Comments Loader Loading Comments