Homeland Security

Is Colonel Purohit guilty?
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
Issue Vol. 23.4 Oct-Dec 2008 | Date : 18 Jul , 2012

Lt Col Srikant Purohit

The article was written one month prior to 26/11 and was published in Indian Defence Review issue No. 23.4 (Oct-Dec 2008) under the the title “Spare the Army“.

Going by the selective and flip-flop leaks by the Anti Terrorist Squad (ATS) of Maharashtra, and the manner in which the media is lapping it up, it appears that there is a concerted and rather a desperate bid to make an ‘Osama bin Laden’ out of Lt Col Purohit and prove that the Sadhavi Pragya and her accomplices are the new ‘Hindu Jehadis’.  The credulity of the general public is being stretched on various scores.

Firstly, the speed at which fresh revelations is being disseminated by the ATS on a daily basis, in complete disregard to professional propriety and in gross prejudice to the ongoing investigation. Secondly, the unprecedented number of ‘Narco Tests’, the accused are being subjected to.  Thirdly, there is a total blank-out with regard to the version of the accused. Fourthly, with every passing day, the network is being enlarged, as if to suggest that the entire country is being consumed by ‘Hindu Terrorism’, and has pan-Indian rather regional and global dimension.

The approach of ‘two wrongs make a right’ or ‘one wrong is equal to another wrong’ does not address the root causes of a problem.

Fifthly, if intercepts of some of the accused was available much prior to the blasts as suggested, then why no pre-emptive measures were taken. Sixthly, no army representative has been included in the interrogation team. Seventhly, the most intriguing aspect is the timing and the developing political tenor of the investigations i.e. during the eve of elections.

No two security problems especially those having religious and social overtones have the same character, motivation and orientation. Any attempt to draw parallels between terrorism of all kinds though politically beneficial can be counter-productive, and detracts the security agencies.

Each form of terrorism, whether home-grown or externally inspired—like Maoist, religious, social, secessionist, and political terrorism—has to be dealt on different planes. Even though, one terrorism feeds on another, the tendency to link various terrorisms, as is happening in the wake of ‘Malegaon case’, must at all costs be avoided.

This is not to say that the entire investigation process is a miscarriage of truth and justice. It was only expected that the chain of terrorist strikes across the nation over the years, wherein innocent people and the country’s integrity and economic interests have been targeted, would at some point of time provoke retaliatory measures in unknown ways. Although words like ‘retaliation’ or ‘reaction’ have become blasphemous in the present Indian context, it however cannot be wished away.

I have deep apprehension that the complete truth, as and when it unfolds in the future, could have several unsavoury and damaging twists.

It is an exercise of responsible and perspicuous governance to ensure that the retaliatory susceptibilities are contained, rather given a positive direction. The approach of ‘two wrongs make a right’ or ‘one wrong is equal to another wrong’ does not address the root causes of a problem. It only contributes to creation of new undesirable elements and organizations, and further polarizes the society. In my interactions with various segments of the society, the polarization in aftermath of ‘Malegaon blasts’ , appears to have grown more acute.

The  investigation following the ‘Malegaon blasts’, is extremely complex in nature due to the alleged involvement of an Army officer belonging to the Military Intelligence. The media therefore needs to be extremely cautious and circumspect about the manner in which it reports the briefs by the ATS. I have deep apprehension that the complete truth, as and when it unfolds in the future, could have several unsavoury and damaging twists.

The Colonel is a legitimate intelligence operative. Interaction with the police authorities, other intelligence agencies, desirable and undesirable elements was very much a part of his duty, without which no intelligence can be gathered and no counter-intelligence operation can be effected. No intelligence agency issues written orders in pursuance of intelligence operations. The entire system is based on trust and faith. It is yet to be established how much of disconnect is there between the legitimate and illegitimate activities of the officer during the course of his duty.

A Military Intelligence officer is hardly competent in providing training on Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs).

The level and extent of intelligence interaction and cooperation with other intelligence agencies that this officer had, is also not known. That is why, it was very important to have a representative of the Military Intelligence, when the interrogation of the officer began. To that extent, a state police organization is not only under-equipped but also out of sync with central intelligence agencies in dealing with an official of Military Intelligence.

There can be no greater travesty in the suggestion by certain quarters that the alleged involvement of Lt Col Purohit is symptomatic of a deeper malaise taking roots in the Indian Army. An officer of the Military Intelligence is not in direct command of troops.  He has only a small complement of personnel working under him. A Military Intelligence officer is hardly competent in providing training on Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs). Importantly, the nation must trust in the legal procedures of the Army, which is far more stringent. The Army will brook no ideology, which impacts on the established secular character and credentials of the organization. As and when Lt Col Purohit is handed back to Army custody, it is inevitable that he will be meted out the appropriate punishment, if found guilty, notwithstanding any misplaced sense of patriotism that he may attempt to invoke. I would therefore request the media to be patient and for the time being spare the Army.

Rate this Article
Star Rating Loader Please wait...
The views expressed are of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the Indian Defence Review.

About the Author

RSN Singh

is a former military intelligence officer who later served in the Research and Analysis Wing, or R&AW and author of books Asian Strategic and Military Perspective and The Military Factor in Pakistan. His latest book is The Unmaking of Nepal.

More by the same author

Post your Comment

2000characters left

14 thoughts on “Is Colonel Purohit guilty?

  1. This whole plot was hatched by the Congress Govt then to appease the minorities. Good our Minorities saw through their game plan and threw out the Congress Govt. Tbe very fact that durin 5 years of their rule, the Congress led UPA Govt could not even file a charge sheet in the Case proves that it was apparently a fake case. Saddest part is a Service Officer being falsely implicated.

  2. Jab tak police political control mein rahegi, criminal investigation sahi nahi ho sakata, an investigation should b finished in 6 months and trial completed within a year without any media coverage till judgment is out. As per norm jab tak saza nahin, accused nahin.

  3. I fail to understand that our media has been too scared to call a Muslim as a Muslim. He is called a minority.All minority people are not Muslim. Then you call him minority Muslim?But this much liberty is not entrusted to our media by their Media houses.After Modi’s win, we find Muslims are some time called as Muslim. .In case we ,as an independent country cannot call a Muslim as a Muslim and always look for guilty Hindu’s only to punish, , we may lose our independence gradually.RSS, Shiv Sena and such brave organisations have kept the reputation of Hindu’s to some extent.Hindu politicians like Dig Vijay Singh calls all terrorists as Hindu terrorist. If our politicians talk such non sense, then God only can help Hindus.

  4. Does your blog have a contact page? I’m having problems locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail.
    I’ve got some suggestions for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it grow over time.

  5. The current trend seems to suggest that the ARMY is very happy disowning its own. Under the current dispensation cases of army patrol leaders getting arrested by the civil police in the NE are common occurance. God have mercy on the Army and India.

  6. Whole issue is a case of selective leak to present a larger-than-life image of “saffron terror”. Secularist of the country love it. Purohit was a Lt Col in Indian Army not in Pakistan Army. We all know the reach of a middle level officer in our army. Where did he get RDX from? Army does not use RDX as staple explosive. It uses PEK and gun cotton explosive. RDX is only available in the artillery and tank ammunition, which cannot be taken out for obivous reasons. No intelligence corps officer can assemble an IED, leave alone train others. Purohit should be given a fair trial. Only hope he is not a fall guy for someone else.et

  7. No he is not all guilty. He is a very honourable officer. He was called by Maharastra ATS to give lectures. He has been framed by Chidabaram, Indian Express and Headlines Today—three most shady quarters entrusted with the task of fabricating Hindu Terrorism.He has been let down by the dishonorable senior officers of the army. You are ready to play cricket with Pakistan after the ”2611 WAR’ inflicted by Pakistan on India and you are not ready to release this patriotic officer! By the way whom was he terrorizing?

  8. The prescience of the author is remarkable. Difficult to believe that this article was written four years back in 2008. It is also difficult to believe that no charge-sheet has been furnished by the investigating agencies against Lt Col Purohit even after four years. Meanwhile, he is languishing in the prison. If that is the price for integrity, dedication, professionalism and patriotism… Shame on India and more so shame on the Indian Army. Hindu terrorism is nothing but a political move to balance terror for the exigency of vote-bank politics orchestrated by Mr. Chidambaram and the Indian Express.

More Comments Loader Loading Comments