Latest...
 
 

It is time to wake up to Chinese incursions

 

Kiren Rijiju, the 36-year-old firebrand Member of Parliament representing Arunachal Pradesh (West), does not share the government’s and Indian Army’s perceptions about Chinese incursions in his border state.

While Defence Minister A K Antony and army chief General Deepak Kapoor have underplayed the intrusions on several occasions, Rijiju has tried to convey in Parliament the seriousness of the situation in the strategic state. Unfortunately till now his voice has been lost in the corridors of power.

The Chinese (intrusions) are happening in a slow, creeping manner. Inch by inch, the Chinese station their army personnel and bring equipment.

Rijiju has pointed out for long that the Indian Army is not prepared for a conflict with China and today this is an accepted fact. The young MP still regrets that only cosmetic actions are being taken to correct this imbalance.

In this wide-ranging interview with Claude Arpi, the MP highlights not only the patriotism of the people of Arunachal, but also conveys in the strongest terms that it is time for India to wake up, to be self-confident and to stand by her interests and her borders.

Chinese intrusions have been denied by the army and the government, but you have repeatedly brought the matter to public notice. Could you tell us what is really happening?

In my constituency in Arunachal (West), there are many points where Chinese intrusions are happening. And it happens throughout the year. Since the 1962 war, the Government of India has not developed adequate infrastructure on the border. This has made access to the border very difficult from our side; while on the Chinese side, they have built infrastructure to facilitate movement of their army and people. Their side is far more accessible.

The Chinese (intrusions) are happening in a slow, creeping manner. Inch by inch, the Chinese station their army personnel and bring equipment.

But the real issue is that India after 1962 adopted a secret policy not to develop the border areas. The idea behind it is that if we develop the border areas, the Chinese can easily use these facilities in the event of a war. It is a wrong policy.

Is it the army or grazers?

Grazers are basically a camouflage because the terrain is very difficult. I am speaking of areas from eastern Arunachal (Walong) to the western part (Tawang). The public (and the government) only know of Chinese incursions if it happens in known places like Tawang. When incidents happen in more remote places, it does not come to the notice of the general public. The army keeps it secret. They won’t let the people know what actually happened.

In one place in Tawang district, some villagers were in possession of rice and grain supplied by the Chinese authorities. When these Monpa tribals were asked they took Chinese help, they answered: “Well, we have not been supplied with essential commodities from the Indian side. To survive we had no other choice but to accept what the Chinese offered.” This shows that the government is not doing enough for the development of the border areas.

But the real issue is that India after 1962 adopted a secret policy not to develop the border areas. The idea behind it is that if we develop the border areas, the Chinese can easily use these facilities in the event of a war. It is a wrong policy. It means that we are in a defensive mode, we have no confidence in our army. This encourages the Chinese. We have to be confident in our own policies. Our demand has been that we should connect all the border areas right to the McMahon Line by a road network.

Do you think that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit to Arunachal, though he did not visit Tawang, opened the eyes of the government?

The government is now realising the hard realities, but it is still committing the same mistake. Why did the PM avoid Tawang? By not going, he has given some leverage to the Chinese who can say ‘he has not gone to Tawang, because it is a disputed territory’. It is an acknowledgement that it is disputed, while in fact it is not. The PM’s decision gives justification to Chinese claims and encourages them.

Click to buy: Tibet: The Lost Frontier

When they found out that the PM was going to Itanagar only, the Chinese knew that their pressure tactics had worked. Arunachal is the only issue which has a potential for conflict between India and China. If ever, India and China go to war one day, it will be on this issue.

There is already a full deployment in Tibet, including nuclear weapons. In fact till 2005, they could not move heavy military equipment due to bad roads. The railway connectivity has dramatically changed the geopolitics of Tibet.

Do not forget that Arunachal is (potentially) the richest state in India. About 30 percent of the power will come from Arunachal alone. Arunachal has petroleum; gas, minerals, and the largest forested area in India. Arunachal has great water resources. India is going to face a water shortage. Our state has a great potential, it is going to be the richest state in India in 15 years. The Chinese know this.

What if the Chinese divert the Brahmaputra river?

It will be only on the Siang (Brahmaputra) which represents only 25 percent of the waters of the state. Most of rivers flow from the Arunachal side of the McMahon Line which is the dividing line on the top of the ridge. All the rivers which originate from the Indian side flow towards India and cannot be diverted. Their flow increases in Arunachal.

The Chinese have built a new airport in Nyintri district in Tibet, just north of the McMahon line.

This airport is very close to Arunachal. On the belt along the Brahmaputra (Tsangpo) river, towards Arunachal, particularly from Tsona (north of Tawang) to the Yunnan province (of China), the Chinese have built adequate infrastructure with many airports. Further, the Golmund-Lhasa railway line will be soon extended till Shigatse (Southern Tibet), it should be completed next year.

They announced it for 2010?

But Chinese are always able to complete their projects before schedule. They will reach Shigatse in 2009 and then, turn eastwards following the Tsangpo basin towards Tsona. Once it reaches Tsona, we will have a massive deployment of military hardware, right on the Arunachal border.

There is already a full deployment in Tibet, including nuclear weapons. In fact till 2005, they could not move heavy military equipment due to bad roads. The railway connectivity has dramatically changed the geopolitics of Tibet.

All the brains of the ministry of external affairs and the think-thanks in India are obsessed with two countries only: The US and Pakistan. How many people know about China, whether it is in the defence or intelligence fields? India does not understand what China is.

India’s plan to counter this move is not enough. The recent package for a trans-Arunachal road which will cost Rs 6,000 crore or Rs 7,000 crore only connects the lower districts of Arunachal. Nowhere will this touch the McMahon Line.

I have written to the prime minister asking him to make sure that the road connectivity touches all the border areas. Otherwise, it will not serve the (defence) purpose. From the package announced by the prime minister, all border points will be five or six days by foot.

How can military personnel take care of our borders when they have to walk five or six days with arms and ammunition? I am honestly admitting that we are not prepared.

It was also admitted by A K Antony during a visit to Sikkim.

Yes, he admitted it and I have said it in Parliament for so many years. For years, the government denied it. Now they have accepted my point. The question remains ‘What have you done so far (to solve it)?’ I would like also to mention that the people of Arunachal are very patriotic; it is a positive point. It is the same thing in Ladakh and other hilly areas. We are honest, patriotic and nationalist people.

The Centre today undermines the peaceful nature of these people. It may be very explosive and costly for the country if this situation goes on and if the people of the Himalayas who act as sentries for the nation, are ignored.

The negative policy of the Centre should be reversed; the passive attitude should become active.

Let us continue to have good relations with the US. But why be obsessed with them? While news in Washington or Lahore make headlines here, nobody knows about the border areas.

Is there some understanding in the government?

I am telling them: “Don’t fear China, just do your job. Help the people of border areas with roads, schools, hospitals, telecom facilities.” This is the solution. We do not want a war with China.

Arunachal should not be the bone of contention between India and China, it should be the bridge. We have five traditional border posts with China (Tibet), it should be reopened. There should be more people to people contact.

Some ten years back I visited Arunachal. At that time, there was talk of opening the Bumla Pass for trade. What is the position today?

Click to buyToday there is a fear psychosis vis-a-vis China. India wants only sea trade with China. India thinks that if we have a land trade relations, Chinese goods will flood the Indian market. Look at Nathu-la (in Sikkim), it was opened two years back, nothing happened. We have to increase the volume of trade. Even in the case of Nathu-la, India curtailed the process by not putting in place adequate infrastructure.

 
Rate this article
 
 
 

About the author

Claude Arpi writes regularly on Tibet, China, India and Indo-French relations. He is the author of Tibet: The Lost Frontier and Dharamshala and Beijing: the negotiations that never were.

 

Reader's Response 4 Posts | Submit your Post

 
Posted on: February 9, 2012 at 01:57 AM
Posted by: marshal panda

It is really surprising that, successive governments in India have not realized the fact that there is no second prize in war .

Posted on: February 9, 2012 at 01:57 AM
Posted by: marshal panda

It is really surprising that, successive governments in India have not realized the fact that there is no second prize in war .

Posted on: March 15, 2011 at 04:24 AM
Posted by: robert david

We need men of the calibre of Raju and Arpi to inject some urgency into national defence.If one carefully analyses the Chinese deployment in Tibet they are at a grave disadvantage from the purely military point of view.They rely on massive troop movements and building of infrastructure to scare us.Our press does the rest to ensure that the leadership is too scared to mention, leave alone prepare for countering the Chinese threat.The roar of a lion is powerful enough to freeze his prey into trembling inaction.It cannot dive into its hole nor can it take to flight.The lion then has easy pickings.This is what the entire Chinese strategy is all aboutA dispassionate appreciation of the Chinese deployment will reveal that they are completely dependant on their Golmud Lhasa railway which is at times suspended on pylons hundreds of feet high and at times goes through long tunnels bored into prrmafrost mountains .Both pylons and mouths of tunnels can be neutralised for years by a single Agni attack or a Shukoi raid.The other two long switchback mountain roads from Sichuan rising 18,000 ft into Tibet takes 2 weeks to travel by bus .These roads can be easily be put of action by missiles or the IAF causing landslides and craters. It is then an easy matter to convert the PLA depots and storage areas into flaming ruins.In case they plan to attack they can only come through clearly defined passes which can be covered by massed machine guns and long range anti aircraft guns firing high explosive fragmentation rounds in rapid fire mode.No infantry can get through that. If they plan to do mass paradropping the terrian is such that it lends itself to hundreds of ambushes in lush jungle terrian in steep mountain sides and deep gorges.Our boys recruited from the local population know the land well, the Chinese dont.Is it any wonder that they hope that the roar of the dragon will freeze our leadership into such inaction that they can just walk into Arunachal Pradesh without a fight

Posted on: March 2, 2011 at 09:15 AM
Posted by: Piyush

Sir,I shoot 100s of email to citizens and tried to create awareness from 2008 till 2009 on CHinese Incusions.I also mailed HON M.P Rijiju and has talked once on phone that I stay at Mumbai and doing JOB. I also send some articles to Media also but dont know they shown or Not. But nothing is lost till everything is Lost. Since 3 years i also always comment on china that time is running out fast and Govt need to speed defence and infrastucture work in Arunachal and border areas. Why cant we deploy 2 lacs worker and finish work in 2 years instead of 5-7 years. We failed to Build Military Industrial COmplex but still we can but HUge arms to match up against china. Why our leaders Shy to speak out openly against China? and tolerating KOW -TOW? India still need to Imprt 2000 Tanks, 400 Fighter Jets and more than 2 dozens NUclear submarnies and warships. this things are not readily available in market. I read Nostradamus Book also on Future 3rd world war and India. Existence of Pakistan is doubt

Post your Comment: