Indian Defence Review Online

Chinese Special Forces cut off Siliguri corridor: 2012

By Bharat Verma
Issue: Vol 25.2 Apr-Jun 2010


India has the potential to be to Asia, what America is to the world – a symbol of hope, liberty and freedom.

Closed societies like China or Pakistan do not fit the bill. Due to authoritarian regimes in Beijing and Islamabad, in times to come they will remain preoccupied with growing internal societal turmoil. Therefore, they will naturally tend to threaten democratic India, militarily and with the help of their irregular forces to divert attention from the brewing internal storm. Particularly true, as on one hand, the Indian democracy negates their authoritarian philosophy, and on the other, the Union is perceived as a soft target to be conquered or cause rupture.

But technology driven 21st century cannot be China’s century in Asia as is being touted by its proxy Pakistan or the Chinese themselves. Simply as these are very brittle, regressive and perpetually paranoid societies that cannot sustain such enlarged influence as they get into an over reach. While the People’s Liberation Army, the largest in the world consists of 3.5 million soldiers to project power; Beijing employs whopping twenty-one million to police the dissent internally!

Military threat from such dictatorial regimes will increase to free societies as the western democracies retreat from Asia. There already exists a severe trust deficit between China and the small countries in the region.

Possibly India is the only country in Asia that boasts of the potential to occupy the strategic high ground gradually being vacated by the retreating western forces, provided it develops offensive orientation at the political level. Unlike China, its soft power increasingly impacts on Asia. The young demographic profile will continue to propel Indian economy to greater heights at least till end of the year 2050. China’s ageing profile shows trends that it will, first grow old then rich, unlike Japan, which grew rich then old. India if governed fairly well, will grow rich and then old like Japan.

India’s multi-ethnic, multi-cultural and multi-religious society is the melting pot in Asia that benefits from rich diversity and open society. However, it is not as fortunate to be situated geographically in a safe haven like America, which is surrounded by nations with similar values.

THE HISTORICAL THREAT

Historically, the direction of demographic flow for centuries saw invasions from Central Asia to capture Delhi. Every fifty to hundred years, the subcontinent due to the genius of natives tends to generate wealth. From time immemorial this attracted hordes of invaders from Central Asia. Delhi Durbar was unable to defend itself as it neglected its military. Time and again, the rulers in Delhi were subjugated, as their incompetence in wielding the military was pathological.

map

Once again India is generating vast wealth. Once again it refuses to defend it!

Despite historical lessons of defeat at the hands of marauding armies, Delhi Durbar’s incompetence and ignorance in equipping the excellent military machine inherited from the British is again on display. Today the danger of disruption to the Union is much higher than in the previous centuries. Worse, the lack of offensive orientation in political thinking degrades the ability of the military to defend the Union from the extraordinary threat developing on its borders.

The level of danger continues to creep north from “orange” to “red” on our land borders primarily on two counts. First, as a deception plan Pakistan on its birth, professed to be secular, while in reality the leaders wanted a purely Islamic state. As a result the minority Hindu population of more than thirteen percent in a population of 76 million in 1947 got reduced to barely two percent even as the population of Pakistan increased in 2004 to 156 million. After refusing to share power with the Bengalis in the East and breaking up their country, the Pakistani Sunnis not satisfied with this calibrated purge, now want to eliminate the Shias and expel the Ahmadiyas from Islam.

More by Bharat Verma

    •  Unmasking China
    • China will fight India to the last Pakistani!
     Pakistan: the Jihad Factory
     Unprepared and Unwilling

In its devious journey towards fundamentalist Islam, it also wants to lock the women folk inside their homes under Taliban diktat, thus negating fifty percent of its population. This dangerous religious philosophy based on extreme form of imported Wahabi Islam is intolerant of worldview of others, wields nuclear weapons, nurtures a Talibanised army that runs a large irregular guerrilla force solely motivated by Islamic fundamentalism, and partners China. The ideology of Pakistan is in direct confrontation with the values cherished by India.

Worse, Pakistan’s financial bankruptcy exacerbates the internal instability. This in turn provides cheap human resource, to be used as cannon fodder, by the Jihad Factory run by the ISI. One feeds on the other. Islamic fundamentalism occupies Pakistan’s political space that in turn negates Indian influence, which wisely extended up to Afghanistan during British rule. It was the British Indian Army that kept a check on the repeat of a history of invasions from Central Asia.

Ironically, instead of consolidating and integrating Kashmir, pacifist New Delhi is permitting the birth of a similar pocket of influence with extreme philosophy in the valley that will come back to haunt India in the near future.

THE THREAT FROM NORTH

Second, to add to the woes of New Delhi, a bigger threat in addition to the existing one is posed by communist China. While too much ‘god’ motivates Pakistan, China pretends to be a ‘godless’ state. Unlike nations that boast of an army, in Pakistan the army owns the state. On the other hand, in China the People’s Liberation Army is loyal to the Chinese Communist Party and not the state. Dissent in both is a ‘no-no’ in varying degrees. Both, Pakistan and China, unlike India are paranoid about open societies. Thus, Beijing and Islamabad share commonality of purpose and together direct their energies to upstage India in international forums, on the borders and by fomenting internal dissent. In a unique ‘jointmanship,’ Islamabad clandestinely transfers sensitive defence technology it receives from the west to Beijing on ‘barter basis’ as there is ban on transfer to China!

The concurrent rise of China and India pits them against each other, as they compete for the same resources, but one with an authoritarian regime that is scared of Dalai Lama and Google, and the other with a free society that revels in religion, Dalai Lama and Google.

Threat from China was evident from its maps in 1946. Mao with the help of these maps described Tibet as the palm of a hand with its five fingers – Ladakh, Sikkim, Nepal, Bhutan and NEFA as Chinese territories that needed to be liberated. Tibet was liberated by force while New Delhi slept. Nepal found India’s refusal to defend Tibet as a sign of an unreliable ally and thought it prudent to open communications with Beijing.

Today India stands encircled by China.

THE THREAT PERCEPTION

To be supreme in Asia, and impelled by the necessity to divert the attention from the growing internal turmoil, Beijing is likely to design a limited but visible military victory in a joint strategy with Islamabad. Pakistan under severe threat of fragmentation would be more than a willing ally.

With Afghanistan being abandoned by the West, beginning July 2011, Islamabad will craft a strategy to take over Kabul with the help of Islamic fundamentalist groups. The irony is that in the aftermath of the exit of the West; Taliban will occupy the Parliament being built by India in Kabul and connive disruption from there of the Indian Union. These groups will not target the West immediately since the latter retains the ability to re-intervene once inaction is deemed as ’suicidal’. The Taliban will initially concentrate on unraveling a soft target like India in concert with Beijing -Islamabad -Kabul or Chinese Communists- Pakistan Army- Irregular Forces axis.

The physical threat to India will materialize in 2012, after the exit of the American forces from Afghanistan. Earlier India had to contend with a single threat from its West/Central Asia. Now another threat posed from the North under a joint strategy between China and Pakistan has emerged.

The developing scenario suggests that henceforth GHQ Rawalpindi will further orchestrate provocation against India to regain lost ground in J&K by way of rallies in PoK or Lahore and through military machinations on our borders. It will provide fillip to terrorist attacks, export of fake currency, inserting terrorists in India through Nepal, activation of sleeper cells, and raising controversy on non-issues like water. Beijing while talking ambiguously up to 2012 buildup will continue to support the Maoists in Nepal and step up training and funding to Maoist in India. The intensity of Cyber War will meanwhile increase.

In nutshell, the objective will be to keep India off balance.

THE STRATEGY

By 2012, to unravel India, Beijing is likely to para-drop a division of its Special Forces inside the Siliguri Corridor to sever the Northeast. There will be simultaneous attacks in other parts of the border and linkup with the Special Forces holding the Siliguri Corridor will be effected. All these will take place under the nuclear overhang. In concert Islamabad will activate the second front to unhook Kashmir by making offensive moves across the IB in the plains and the desert to divide Indian reaction capability. Meanwhile the fifth columnists supporting these external forces will unleash mayhem inside.

Two key question for New Delhi:

  1. Will India go nuclear if its territorial integrity is threatened? France’s stated policy is that it will use the nuclear option, if Germany is attacked. Germany is not likely to face a nuclear adversary, yet France will use nuclear option if it is attacked. India faces threat from two nuclear powers in its vicinity. Will India shift its stated position of second strike to first strike, if the territorial integrity of the Union is under threat?
  2. Will New Delhi have the gumption to order the Navy to retaliate and stop the flow of cargo in the Indian Ocean being freighted to China? Or will it order the Air Force to conduct offensive and decisive strategic strikes inside Tibet?

New Delhi requires to develop offensive orientation in its thinking for the answers to be in affirmative. India has produced more than its share of great thinkers in civil affairs. However, being a pacifist society, it does not boast of a single military thinker of repute. Therefore, we should not hesitate to import knowledge from the best military thinkers to create an assertive society, just in the same way, as we need to import the best defence technologies to set up the most modern defence industry hub that ensures expansion of democratic space in Asia.

The ideal opportunity for China to dismember India is between 2011 and 2014 on multiple counts. First, to divert attention from the growing dissent within. Second, beyond this period, Pakistan as a fragmented nation may not exist to support the Chinese. Third, the change of generation by 2015 will witness an assertive India. Fourth, the new Indian assertiveness will ensure rapid modernization of the Armed Forces with robust military capabilities. Last but not the least, given the fact it does not pose threat to any country, India will create strong international alliances. It is in a unique position and gets along well with the West, as well as countries like Russia and others. In fact, the international opinion will decisively tilt in favour of India if it shrewdly deals the powerful geo-economic card held in the arsenal.

Popular Books on China

Tibet: The Lost Frontier  
Dharamshala and Beijing: the negotiations that never were  

The answer to the outlined nightmare stares India on its face.

India simply needs to take out the cost-benefit ratio from the game plan of the opponent by rapidly acquiring the requisite military muscle that outguns and outclasses the adversary. War is akin to business. If there is no cost-benefit ratio, it cannot be imposed! Such assertive actions will also naturally propel India in Asia as the most influential player and arrest the slide of retreating democracies.

Bharat Verma, Editor Indian Defence Review and author of the book Fault Lines and Indian Armed Forces.

Copyright 2010 indiandefencereview.com All Rights Reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Indian Defence Review is prohibited.

July 15th, 2010 .


6 Responses to “Chinese Special Forces cut off Siliguri corridor: 2012”

  1. arun subramaniyan Says:

    Frightening yet excellent!I am confident that the politico-bureaucratic setup is not prepared for or don’t foresee the eventualities listed here.

  2. Rajiv Kumar Kaul Says:

    The 2 front War is a real possibility. I disagree with Mr. Verma on many issues. Firstly, what use is a nation to its people and others that “revels” in appearances and practices few universal principles. Please allow me to offer an example. It is has become internationally fashionable and financially remunerative for Indians in India and abroad to condemn China and align against it than to seek a mutually beneficial arrangement with it and Asia. There are many leaders in India who have rotted and truly perished but not attained approbation amongst their Indian brothers – for harmonising with China.
    Secondly, I believe China is prepared to attack India anytime and if a rapproachment is missing and our relationships with the West increase – the rest as you predict may ensue.
    India must enhance its military machinery and force drastically. We must match the 30 million number in military, paramilitary and NCC forces.
    The numbers around the North East, Nepal borders should augment appreciably.
    Whatever it takes, we should bring Bhutan and Bangladesh to our side.
    I feel very soon we should crush Pakistan in a war which they will start in a skirmish along the LOC.
    China will enter the fray. We will be ready. The matters will not continue beyond the removal of the China-Pakistan potential axis.
    Thirdly, I dont think its that easy for the North East to fall. The Chinese tried it in 197? and failed. They will get beaten very badly this time.
    However, the 2 front scenario accompanied by the worthless navy we presently have – is a real dangerous threat.
    Mr. Verma should convince the GOI to work expeditiously on his ideas. Its good to see, he has developed nationalistic feelings of inadequacy after basking for years under the Nehruvian and Indira Gandhi vision of secularism. LOL.
    Another thing, if we lose the North East and Kashmir do we have a nation – the armies of Pakistan and China right above us.
    Thank you.

  3. Veerpartap Singh Chohan Says:

    The best option for India is to attack before china attacks and to surprise them.

  4. RAT Says:

    INDIA HAS TO BE PREPARED FOR A 6 SIDED WAS
    1 FROM THE NORTH
    2 FROM THE WEST
    3 FROM BURMA SIDE
    4 FROM THE EAST I DEFIENTLY DO NOT TRUST THE BANGLADESHIS
    5 INTERNAL THERAT FROM THE NAXALS PRO CHINIESE
    6 CYBER ATTACKS

    THE BEST OPTION INDIA HAS TO DECAPITATE THE FALLEN STATE RISE OFFESNSIVE FORCES AND HAVE A INDEPENDENT NAVY TO TAKE ON MIGHT OF COUNTRIES LIKE PAKISTAN OR BANGLADESH IF REQUIRED

    i do not want my name to be published nor my identity known

  5. Sumit Walia Says:

    Excellent analysis by Capt. Verma. He has not only tried to see what lies in future (keeping the current scenario un mind)& has provided reasons for the future confrontations. It might not happen in 2012 but it is bound to happen. Alarm bells are ringing in Riasina hills, thats why Govt is taking some steps to bolster defence on NE border like raising 2 Mountain divisions to man NE border speacilly for any Chinese mis-advanture, buying Ultralight howitzers, C-130s & C-17s from US etc. But New Delhi is not appreciating the gravity of the situation in a way it should. That is why its not paying due attention to dramatically increase the infrastructure in NE. In another 2 years, China will celebrate Golder Jublee of their 1962 victory against india & we still dont have proper road infrastructure in NE states.We dont even have any plan of improving our diplomatic relations with anyof the neighbouring countries.

  6. BRAHMASTRA Says:

    An excellent article. India can also meet the challenge from China through two ways. One is by increasing the level of defence preparedness and ensuring a greater say for serving and retired defence personnel in some aspects of state policy, similar to what is being done in many democracies like France or USA. The second is by adopting a more pro-active diplomatic approach. As the author has rightly pointed out, the Government of China lacks political legitimacy. Hence,Taiwan can be treated as the real China and India should consider establishment of diplomatic relations with Taiwan. The political setup in China may collapse on the weight of a major political upheaval. Pakistan is on the verge of total collapse and it is the jihadi forces in Pakistan who are more powerful than the State of Pakistan, that need to be reckoned.

Leave a Comment